New Year’s Eve in New York City is one of the most exciting times of the year, and what better way to ring in the new year than with a memorable dinner? From elegant multi-course meals to indulgent seafood spreads, here are the top five spots in NYC to enjoy a fabulous New Year’s Eve dinner.
1. Smithereens
Location: 159 W 10th St, New York, NY 10014
If you’re looking for a New England-inspired New Year’s Eve dinner, Smithereens offers a delectable surf-and-turf menu that will elevate your celebration. The restaurant offers two seating options: a 6 pm seating for $195 and a 9 pm seating for $225. The six-course meal includes luxurious dishes like lobster, beef sirloin, and smoked bluefish with caviar on buckwheat pancakes. Guests at the second seating can also enjoy a festive champagne toast at midnight. Optional wine pairings are served from magnums, making it a celebratory experience you won’t want to miss.
2. Lundy Bros
Location: 43 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Lundy Bros. is a legendary New York City institution, originally founded in 1916 and now located in Red Hook, Brooklyn. On New Year’s Eve, the restaurant offers a delicious seafood-filled menu, starting with appetizers like oysters Rockefeller and crispy calamari, followed by main courses like prime rib with horseradish sauce ($120), butter-poached lobster ($140), or Alaska sockeye salmon with caviar sauce ($115). The restaurant also serves shareable sides and tempting desserts to cap off the meal. Make sure to secure your reservation for a dinner experience that brings the charm of this historic restaurant into the new year.
3. Four Twenty Five
Location: 425 Park Ave, New York, NY 10022
For those looking for a glamorous dining experience to celebrate the arrival of 2025, Jean-Georges’ Four Twenty Five offers a luxurious five-course tasting menu. Guests can enjoy dishes such as charred duck breast, butter-poached lobster, seared beef tenderloin, and roasted squash agnolotti. The festive gala dinner starts at 8 pm and includes party favors and complimentary bubbly at midnight to toast to the new year. For those not in the mood for the tasting menu, an à la carte option will be available from 5 pm to 7 pm. Don’t miss out on securing your spot for this elegant celebration.
4. Blackbarn
Location: 19 E 26th St, New York, NY 10010
Blackbarn is a sophisticated farm-to-table restaurant offering a luxurious New Year’s Eve prix fixe menu for $185 per person ($235 with wine pairings). The meal begins with a caviar tasting that includes Sevruga caviar paired with vichyssoise, Osetra spooned onto deviled eggs, and trout roe on smoked salmon rillette with chilled lemon vodka. For the main course, choose between pan-seared diver scallops with confit porcini risotto or filet mignon and tiger prawn with potato fondant and Creole bearnaise sauce. Finish off the meal with indulgent desserts like eggnog cheesecake or warm apple cider doughnuts. Celebrate the last night of the year in style with this exquisite feast.
5. Le Crocodile
Location: 271 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Le Crocodile offers a chic and festive four-course prix fixe dinner, with dishes like steak tartare, black truffles, lobster risotto, and a wintry vegetable Wellington. Guests can pair their meals with an extensive list of Champagne to really get into the celebratory spirit. For those looking to splurge, they also offer magnum bottles to make a grand toast to the upcoming year. Dinner is priced at $163 per person, and reservations are highly recommended for this stylish celebration of the new year.
